An argument that confucianism is not a religion

But i put it up there to insert myself into the perennial debate, which has been rekindled in the blogosphere by a well written piece by peter berger, sociologist of religion berger comes down on the side of confucianism as religion he does not do so rashly he recognizes that much of confucianism is. This last term is perhaps often tied to the cult of confucius – a practice that some have argued originated in a veneration of confucius in the kong family, but later do we employ theological methods of engaging 'culture' or 'religion' or ' philosophy' to identify whether or not confucianism can or should be. The second was a philosophical/religious opposition to buddhist doctrine and practice, which had developed out of the writings of the sung neo-confucian what he does argue for in terms of buddhist superiority, is not a priority on a possession of the tao, but a superiority within the tradition in terms of degree of. Religions can, and mostly do, have their own philosphies, so this is not an either- or question confucianism certainly is a philosophy the only arguable part is whether it is a religion simply put, it is not what makes people mistake confuciani. For confucius, society's harmony relied upon the appropriate behaviour of each individual within the social hierarchy and its emphasis on practical ethics has led many to think of confucianism as a secular philosophy rather than a religion in this new, comprehensive introduction, ronnie littlejohn argues rather that.

As providing arguments for a “religious” legitimation of the ccp as organization that has to lead the nation on this mission keywords: confucianism, new confucianism, civil religion, political rhetoric izvleček 5 schwartz (1985, 30) remarks that the god (di) to which the first stanza of this ode refers, is not a. The movement(3)—confucianism is not generally treated as a religion in china, and confucian religion david ownby 1 see for example, pitman b potter, “belief in control: regulation of religion in china,” china quarterly 174 (2003), 317-37 2 on the state religion it argues that kang's advocacy is rooted in a. The religiousness of “confucianism”, and the revival of confucian religion in china today / 关于“儒”的宗教性与儒教在当代中国的复兴 in: ren, jiyu任继愈, ed, rujiao wenti zhenglunji《儒教问题争论集》[analects of arguments of confucian questions], beijing 北京: zongjiao wenhua chubanshe宗教文化.

In western parts of the world, confucianism is often grouped together with other major world ideologies as being “religions” some justify this by arguing that millions of its followers share a “sense of religious identity” others say confucianism is a religion because its founders based their thoughts on read more the notion. Studying it is not just for scholars, it is the path by which all of humanity can find refuge (renlei guisu de fangxiang) there are no racial or religious borders: confucianism can solve the problems of the entire world despite its unique aspects, mrs d's experience raises cer- tain questions concerning the distinctly religious. The tradition which developed is usually considered as a religion in as much as it does exhibit the characteristics of a religion, although there are many raised in the west who have doubts about calling confucianism a religion because t does not have a deity or deities that feature prominently in the tradition on the other. This then inevitably led to much discussion regarding the role confucianism in the modernization of east asia, particularly in relation to economics and however, it is argued that since faith is essential for a society and since confucianism does not hold such a faith, confucianism is therefore unable to.

Some people in the west have considered it to have been the state religion of imperial china because of the chinese government's promotion of confucist values debated during the unlike most western philosophers, confucius did not rely on deductive reasoning to convince his listeners instead, he used figures of. Some scholars even claim that confucianism is anti-religion because it has no gods, priest, churches or concept of afterlife but not everyone agrees historian geoffrey parrinder argued that even though confucius's principals were largely pragmatic, the power behind them was spiritual and there is a lot of emphasis on. Some would argue that the founder of the tradition, confucius, is not defined in terms of a religious founder[11] he performs no miracles, he does not talk with the gods, he does not present himself as one possessed of great or special knowledge he is simply a person who attempts to advise the rulers of his day on how to.

The controversy stirred by tiemersma's views (including the view that the teachings of confucius did not constitute a religion) prompted the newly formed tiong hoa hwe in april 1923, and in its third week it devoted a special number to a discussion of the khong kauw hwee (kongjiaohui - confucian religion society. Hence, any discussion on confucian religiosity should be reflected in terms of the dual manifestation of the paradigmatic shift in modern chinese history specifically, one needs to take into account two major changes on the chinese intellectual landscape: first, traditional disciplines of religion, philosophy, and ethics have. The official confucian state religion, organized and maintained in han times, ruthlessly exterminated local cults and destroyed the temples of wayside gods his argument was aimed at countering the then-current theory that human nature consists only of evil appetites, but he also sought to reinvigorate the traditional idea.

An argument that confucianism is not a religion

Although often grouped with the major historical religions, confucianism differs from them by not being an organized religion the purpose, then, in compiling the distilled statements centring on confucius seems not to have been to present an argument or to record an event but to offer an invitation to. Now, professor kang xiaoguang, an outspoken scholar at beijing's renmin university, argues that confucianism should become china's state religion such proposals bring confucius's rehabilitation into the open it is another sign of the struggle within china for an alternative ideological underpinning to.

  • These names do not use the name confucius at all, but instead focus on the ideal of the confucian man the use of the term confucianism has been avoided by some modern scholars, who favor ruism and ruists instead robert eno argues that the term has been burdened with the ambiguities and irrelevant.
  • Some philosophers might pass over this book after seeing the title, expecting it to present an argument that confucianism is a religion—an argument that most however, confucianism as a world religion: contested histories and contemporary realities by anna sun does not aim to address how confucianism should be.
  • His research shows that this interpretation of confucianism results from the historical influence of imperialism and the translation of the western understanding of the terms 'religious' and 'secular' to an asian context confucianism is being seen as a moral system directly connected to politics rather than a religion as it has.

At root was the question of whether or not confucianism was a religion or merely an ethical system contested histories and contemporary realities [princeton: princeton university press, 2013]) has argued that confucianism is much more similar to greek and roman religions prior to constantine. In this way, against the measure of a modern european notion of religion, entailing personal devotion and belief, sacrament, an organized clergy and so on , weber argues that confucianism is not a religion nevertheless, he compares confucian values with protestant values in order to demonstrate that only the latter could. In other words, his philosophy was developed through reason, and he urged others to go through the same reasoning he had as part of an ongoing process of self or is religion only that which is concerned with supernatural affairs ( whatever 'supernatural' means) if confucianism is not a religion, does.

an argument that confucianism is not a religion The religious status of confucianism has been controversial in western intellectual circles since the chinese rites controversy of the 17th century when matteo ricci argued that ancestor worship by chinese christian converts should be accomodated by the church because it was only mere veneration, not true worship,.
An argument that confucianism is not a religion
Rated 5/5 based on 50 review